Before you criticize me for the title, I’m not sure if I know what other people feel about this but it has been my belief that Jay Bouwmeester is one of the most overrated players by scouts, media and fans alike. I have voiced this reasoning for the past few years.
He’s been in trade rumors a ton with a possible destination as the Toronto Maple Leafs. I hope to god that doesn’t happen because any team trading for Bouwmeester will get ripped off and isn’t any wonder why the Panthers are trying to trade him? He just isn’t worth the hype.
Let’s discuss why Bouwmeester is so over hyped. He played on the Canadian World Junior team when he was 16. He would play 3 seasons for them amassing 4 points in 21 games. He was much younger then most of the competition as was poised to the be the #1 overall pick in the 2002 draft. In an odd move by the Panthers, they decided to move down to the 3rd spot to take Bouwmeester anyway for the right to switch picks but giving up a 3rd and 4th. He was still considered the #1 pick even if he was picked behind Rick Nash and Kari Lehtonen.
It also helps that he’s a huge 6′4 with decent speed. However, he was the mould of the old school thought of what good defensemen had to be like.
However, to me he’s just another big guy who’s never had the track record nor has the offensive skills to be a top defensemen.
Let’s look at his stats before he was drafted. Jay Bouwmeester has always been a “potential” guy. The term is thrown about 50 times too much with him compared to other defensemen. He never really put up the stats or put up stud numbers. As an 18-year old he put up 61 points in 61 games. His highest ever goal total was just a meager 14 goals. Nothing poor but nothing that screams “stud defensemen”. Keep in mind I’m still calling a worthy 1st round pick but nothing like best of the league-style.
What makes him overrated? He just isn’t that good of an offensive defensemen. He put 16 and 20 points as an 19 and 20 year old. Nothing too bad. However when he played in the minors during the lock year, he was quite average. He didn’t dominate the competition. He had 0 points in 18 playoff games for the AHL Chicago Wolves. In the regular season, in a combined 82 games he had 26 points. Even though this is just a 21-year old kid, he’s definitely not playing like a #1 prospect. 40 points would be ideal.
Back to the NHL, he put up 46 points as a 22-year old which is more like it, amassing 41 points. The last two years he’s been regressing dropping to 42 points and 37 points. He increased his goal total last season to 15 a career high in professional hockey. But he had just 22 assists. Don’t you expect more from a guy who’s earning 4.875 million? (and even more in the 2009/2010 season)
Some notable guys who did better then Bouwmeester: Mike Green, Brent Burns, Ryan Whitney, and Tobias Enstrom.
All those players are all younger and outscored Bouwmeester. Whitney himself was taken 5th of the same draft.
22 assists! Some people will look at the 15 goals and say that’s more valuable. I will beg to differ as it shows he’s limited offensively and does have a big shot. People will start playing the shot more and what’s he going to do? Look at this statistic: Bouwmeester was tied for 7th in shots with 182. The more alarming statistic is not his shooting percentage which is respectable but its the players around him. Every one of the players around him had 50 assists or more except Chris Pronger and Zdeno Chara. Pronger had a dismal season by his standard (6 more games with 16 less points) and Zdeno Chara is hardly a passer and more of a physical presence anyway.
His team has never made the playoffs and that doesn’t seem like that’s going to change any time soon at least with the Panthers. He’s not a winner and he hasn’t put them over the top. He’ll be 25 at the start of the season and his time is running out to reach that “potential” that is always associated with him. Other young guys have passed him and it’s time to stop overhyping the guy.
He’s still a good player don’t get me wrong but he’s just average.